Explore our new Cybersecurity Terms Glossary, explained by our experts.

View the Glossary View the Glossary
PRIVIA

Cybersecurity Terms Glossary

What Are Security Maturity Models?

A security maturity model scores how consistently and deliberately an organisation performs security activities, turning a vague sense of progress into a measurable improvement roadmap.

Illustration for the cybersecurity term Security Maturity Models
Home / Blog / Cybersecurity Terms / What Are Security Maturity Models?
17 November 2026

What Are Security Maturity Models?

What Are Security Maturity Models?

A maturity model measures how an organisation does something, not whether it does it at all. Two companies can both say they perform vulnerability management: one because a diligent engineer runs a scan when he remembers, the other because scanning is scheduled, triaged against asset criticality, tracked to closure, and reported monthly. A compliance checklist scores them the same. A maturity model does not.

That distinction is the reason maturity models have become the standard way to describe a security programme to a board. Progress from level 1 to level 2 across eight practices is a sentence an audit committee understands.

The Underlying Scale

Most models descend from the Capability Maturity Model Integration scale, with five levels that recur in slightly different wording everywhere:

LevelNameWhat it looks like
1InitialWork happens through individual effort; results depend on who is on shift
2RepeatableA documented process exists and is usually followed
3DefinedThe process is standard across the organisation and people are trained in it
4ManagedThe process is measured, with metrics driving decisions
5OptimisingMeasurement feeds deliberate, continuous improvement

The jump that matters most in practice is 1 to 3. Getting from “a talented person does this” to “the organisation does this” survives resignations, which is the real test of a security function.

Models You Will Actually Meet

Running an Assessment That Is Worth the Time

Three choices decide whether the exercise produces change or a chart:

  1. Assess evidence, not intention. A level requires artefacts: tickets, logs, meeting minutes, test results. If nobody can produce them, the level is not met, however confident the interviewee is.
  2. Scope by business unit where reality differs. Averaging a mature payments platform with a newly acquired subsidiary produces a middling score that describes neither and hides the actual risk.
  3. Set a target profile deliberately. Level 5 everywhere is neither achievable nor sensible. Pick the practices where your risk appetite demands higher maturity and accept level 2 elsewhere.

Independent assessment is worth buying at least occasionally. Self-assessment drifts upwards over time, particularly when scores are reported to a board that rewards improvement.

Maturity and Compliance Are Not the Same

Certification against ISO 27001 proves a management system exists and meets requirements; it says little about how well individual practices are performed. Organisations frequently hold a valid certificate while sitting at level 2 on detection and response, which is exactly the combination that produces a surprised board after an incident.

The converse also happens. A high maturity score in a model nobody else recognises will not satisfy a customer who asked for a certificate. Treat the two as answering different questions and present both when the audience is external.

The Common Failure

Maturity theatre is easy to spot in hindsight: an assessment run annually by the same team, scores that rise by a tenth of a point each year, and no corresponding change in how incidents actually go. The antidote is to tie each target level to a dated, owned piece of work, then test the claim independently. If detection maturity went from 2 to 3, a purple team exercise should show more techniques generating alerts than it did last year. When the score moves and the evidence does not, the score is wrong.

If you want a maturity baseline grounded in operational evidence rather than interviews, our SOC maturation services assess capability against tested detection coverage.

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions

What Maturity Level Should We Aim For?

Level 3, meaning defined and consistently applied, is a realistic target for most core practices in a mid-sized organisation. Levels 4 and 5 require measurement infrastructure and dedicated improvement effort that only pays off where the risk justifies it, typically in detection, identity, and vulnerability management. Setting a uniform target across all practices wastes budget on areas that do not need it.

How Often Should Maturity Be Reassessed?

Annually for a full assessment, with lighter quarterly reviews of practices undergoing active improvement. Reassessing more often rarely shows meaningful movement, because maturity changes through sustained process change rather than purchases. After a major incident or acquisition, an out-of-cycle assessment of the affected areas is usually worthwhile.

Is the NCSC Cyber Assessment Framework a Maturity Model?

Not formally. The CAF is outcome-based: each contributing outcome is assessed as achieved, partially achieved, or not achieved against indicators of good practice. In practice organisations use it much as they would a maturity model, tracking movement between those states over time. For UK operators in scope of the NIS Regulations it is the framework competent authorities expect.

Can a Maturity Model Replace Certification?

No. Customers, insurers, and procurement teams ask for certificates because they are independently verified against a published standard. A maturity model is an internal management tool that tells you where to improve and how far you have come. Most organisations run both: certification to satisfy external parties and a maturity model to plan the work behind it.

Related Terms

You May Be Interested In These

Why Is Healthcare a Ransomware Target?

Cybersecurity Terms

17 November 2026

Why Is Healthcare a Ransomware Target?

Read More
What Is UEFI and BIOS Security?

Cybersecurity Terms

17 November 2026

What Is UEFI and BIOS Security?

Read More
What Is the Device Code Flow?

Cybersecurity Terms

17 November 2026

What Is the Device Code Flow?

Read More